Homes for sale in Sumter County

Search homes for sale across Sumter County. Listings range from entry-level options to luxury properties. Browse the active listings below, or refine by price, beds and property type to find the right fit.

202 Properties Found

Villa

$579,000

3114 JEMIMA AVE

3 Bed2 BathMFRG5085633 MLS ID1,594 Sq Ft

REALTY EXECUTIVES IN THE VILLAGES

Single Family Residence

$605,000

1223 HARLEYVILLE LOOP

3 Bed2 BathMFRG5086630 MLS ID2,279 Sq Ft

PREMIER SOTHEBYS INT'L REALTY

Single Family Residence

$544,000

3775 RASPBERRY CT

3 Bed2 BathMFRG5086731 MLS ID1,979 Sq Ft

EXP REALTY LLC

Single Family Residence

$819,900

3520 QUIETWOODS DR

3 Bed2 BathMFRG5086602 MLS ID2,060 Sq Ft

REALTY EXECUTIVES IN THE VILLAGES

Single Family Residence

$475,000

2491 MACKINTOSH CT

3 Bed2 BathMFRG5086652 MLS ID1,656 Sq Ft

SALLY LOVE REAL ESTATE

Single Family Residence

$439,900

5452 ZAJAC AVE

3 Bed2 BathMFRG5086607 MLS ID1,636 Sq Ft

GODFREY REALTY GROUP, INC.

Single Family Residence

$399,000

3732 BARREL LOOP

3 Bed2 BathMFRG5084930 MLS ID1,998 Sq Ft

WORTH CLARK REALTY

Single Family Residence

$274,500

9737 PEPPER TREE PL

4 Bed2 BathMFRP4931746 MLS ID1,828 Sq Ft

KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY SMART 1

Single Family Residence

$1,250,000

1965 EVANS PRAIRIE TRL

3 Bed2 BathMFRG5085911 MLS ID2,109 Sq Ft

REALTY EXECUTIVES IN THE VILLAGES

Single Family Residence

$318,990

1953 IOWA DR

4 Bed3 BathMFRC7496596 MLS ID1,964 Sq Ft

WJH BROKERAGE FL LLC

Industrial

$799,000

4003 COUNTY ROAD 106

0 Bed0 BathMFRG5085677 MLS ID0 Sq Ft

RE/MAX FOXFIRE - LADY LAKE

Single Family Residence

$415,000

1390 FOREST ACRES DR

3 Bed2 BathMFRG5085577 MLS ID2,187 Sq Ft

REALTY EXECUTIVES IN THE VILLAGES

As of September 8, 2026 there are 202 active properties for sale in Sumter County.

Across the 30 most recent listings the highest-priced property is $769,000 and the lowest can be purchased for $1,550, with an average listing price of $370,361.

Homes for sale in Sumter County have an average price of $216 per square foot, based on the 30 most recent listings with an average of 2.8 bedrooms, 2.1 bathrooms, 1,676 square feet of living space.

FREE CONSULTATION

Thinking of buying in Sumter County?

Our local experts guide you from search to closing — no obligation.

Contact an Agent

Search all real estate for sale in Sumter County. See today's new listings and search by beds, baths, home and lot size, listing status and days on market. See all areas in the Counties directory.

Want to purchase a home in Sumter County? Call Aubrey Sawyer at 2345678900 — your local real estate experts are here to help with the Sumter housing market.