Residential Single Family Residence in Myakka City, $2M – $3M

Browse residential single family residence for sale in Myakka City priced $2M – $3M. Active listings updated daily from the MLS.

66 Properties Found

Sort:
Single Family Residence

$2,395,000

515 S OSPREY AVE

4 Bed5 BathMFRA4639121 MLS ID2,798 Sq Ft

PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Single Family Residence

$2,500,000

10501 BRIDGEWOOD DR

6 Bed6 BathMFRTB8349285 MLS ID5,486 Sq Ft

HOME AMERICA REALTY INC

Single Family Residence

$2,100,000

419 RAEHN ST

4 Bed4 BathMFRO6278802 MLS ID4,098 Sq Ft

COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

Single Family Residence

$2,900,000

6640 PEACOCK RD

4 Bed4 BathMFRA4639808 MLS ID3,163 Sq Ft

COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

Single Family Residence

$2,200,000

236 S HARBOR DR #LOT 35

3 Bed3 BathMFRA4639747 MLS ID2,878 Sq Ft

RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP

Single Family Residence

$2,850,000

1808 N CENTRAL AVE

6 Bed4 BathMFRFC307248 MLS ID4,723 Sq Ft

RE/MAX SELECT PROFESSIONALS

Single Family Residence

$2,300,000

1805 DIAMELA ST SANTA MARIA DEV

5 Bed5 BathMFRPR9111644 MLS ID4,108 Sq Ft

ARK REAL ESTATE

Single Family Residence

$2,500,000

6537 GULF OF MEXICO DR

4 Bed5 BathMFRA4639935 MLS ID2,313 Sq Ft

PREMIER SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Single Family Residence

$2,800,000

3005 S MILLER RD

5 Bed6 BathMFRTB8347618 MLS ID5,312 Sq Ft

SIGNATURE REALTY ASSOCIATES

Single Family Residence

$2,095,000

9861 EAGLE PRESERVE DR

3 Bed4 BathMFRD6140270 MLS ID2,675 Sq Ft

COLDWELL BANKER SUNSTAR REALTY

Single Family Residence

$2,150,000

7401 WATERSILK DR

5 Bed6 BathMFRTB8346188 MLS ID5,284 Sq Ft

COASTAL PROPERTIES GROUP INTERNATIONAL

Single Family Residence

$2,335,000

2149 HYDE PARK ST

4 Bed4 BathMFRA4639334 MLS ID2,930 Sq Ft

MCWILLIAMS/BALLARD INC

As of September 7, 2026 there are 66 active properties for sale in Myakka City.

Across the 30 most recent listings the highest-priced property is $2,999,999 and the lowest can be purchased for $2,040,000, with an average listing price of $2,475,417.

Homes for sale in Myakka City have an average price of $716 per square foot, based on the 30 most recent listings with an average of 4.2 bedrooms, 4.6 bathrooms, 3,953 square feet of living space.

Thinking of buying in Myakka City?

Our local experts guide you from search to closing — no obligation.

Contact an Agent

Search all real estate for sale in Myakka City. See today's new listings and search by beds, baths, home and lot size, listing status and days on market. See all areas in the Cities directory.

Want to purchase a home in Myakka City? Call Aubrey Sawyer at 2345678900 — your local real estate experts are here to help with the Myakka City housing market.